The Footwear Files | 2025 Comfort & Style Report by Katherine Kidder

Overall Best

New Balance 2002R

The 2002R has become a staple in the US for its "Refined Future" aesthetic. It utilizes N-ergy shock absorption and Stability Web technology to provide a firm yet comfortable ride that lasts all day.

ProsIconic retro aesthetic, premium arch support, high-quality leather and mesh construction.

ConsHigher price point for the category; suede can be difficult to clean in wet weather.

Best ForIndividuals seeking a stylish, professional-looking sneaker for all-day urban walking.

Max Cushioning

HOKA Bondi 8

The Bondi 8 represents the pinnacle of maximalist cushioning. With its billowed foam and extended heel, it's designed to reduce impact and provide a smooth, balanced transition with every step.

ProsIndustry-leading impact protection, ultra-breathable mesh, lightweight despite its size.

ConsThe bulky "maximalist" silhouette may be polarizing; less stable on uneven terrain.

Best ForPeople standing for 8+ hours or those recovering from foot fatigue.

Urban Traveler

On Cloud 5

Swiss engineering meets American city life. The On Cloud 5 features a unique CloudTec® sole that compresses horizontally and vertically, providing a "firm but soft" sensation unique to the brand.

ProsIncredibly lightweight, speed-lacing system for easy on/off, minimalist aesthetics.

ConsSmall pebbles can get stuck in the sole pods; cushioning feels firmer than foam-only shoes.

Best ForCommuters, travelers, and those who prefer a modern, technical look.

Podiatrist Certified

Skechers GO WALK Arch Fit

Skechers dominates the value-comfort market with the Arch Fit line. Developed with 20 years of data and podiatrist certification, it offers a removable insole that molds to your foot to reduce shock.

ProsUnbeatable price-to-comfort ratio, superior arch support, machine washable.

ConsLess durable than premium brands for high-intensity sports; simple styling.

Best ForPractical shoppers who prioritize foot health and orthotic-level support.

Classic Style

Vans Old Skool (ComfyCush)

The ComfyCush version is a revolutionary update to the legendary Vans silhouette. It features a co-molded construction of foam and rubber for the perfect combination of both comfort and grip.

ProsTimeless iconic look, significantly more comfortable and lighter than original Vans.

ConsStill lacks the technical cushioning of dedicated running shoes; narrow fit.

Best ForStudents, creative professionals, and those who want classic style without the pain.